yeah i converted meadows. it was kinda way town sided, because i knew who the untouchables were, and so when masons revealed , the amount of data we gathered is huge.
I thought cory was good tho, at start, because he voted for loafery, and I scouted Loaf earlier, even before he was on the lynch table, so i knew he was evil, so it gives you a lot of data from who he votes to lynch, and who votes for his lynch, cuz then i can assume who is good/evil
then he did that 'imma give a huge speech on all the players' which basically narrows down the guessing game of who i need to scout for. I picked phantom out of the random ppl that were awol. and just happened we got a werewolf, but honestly with the amount of data on who is towns, eventually mafia wud have died off. if u took it to probability, it was already down to 1/5 of me seer'ing a mafia, and that is with a potential like 11 turns left, which is WAY TO HIGH, for town. like the reason why groups of good knowing who each other is, is then people CAN reveal, that is why you never let good ppl other than seer, who can see, cuz if he reveals, he dies. If the townies can label people as good, and guarantee it, as the game narrows down to the end, it gets increasingly difficult for mafia.
But SB. when loaf called out he was seer, we already knew you were good. He mentioned he seer'd SB, and skydragon. so normally you would assume that 1. if he was mafia he would label 'mafia as good', but then if he dies, ppl would not believe his posts, so he would pick 2 townies. if you were 'seer'd supposedly' and you knew you were a townsperson, and seer wasn't killed at night, then the obvious conclusion would be you voting for him, if you work out the potential scenarios of why he picked u as a town, and the implications.
but yeah, that goldmine u gave us loaf, THX. LOL, once u claimed seer, u basically know you are dead that night. or the day after. so saying nothing would have probably been better, cuz once ur role is revealed, all the information you gave made it very easy to spot, unless you planned your death and so you randomly obscured the information, which wud have been better, imo.
what messed me up was cory's vote to lynch loaf, but possible because u can change votes, i never checked back to see if it cfhanged, but it was the one that got loaf on the lynching block.
shinings death was pretty random, but lucky too.
and lissa was EXTRA inactive, which gave her away :P
I just wanted to get down to 4 people. 1 mafia and 3 masons. It was never going to happen, but then kloudi would tie the lynch vote and bam mafia wins. It was one of the reasons we killed a Mason.
In hindsight we shudda just killed all the masons first
But then again the setup was town favored like walls said so it really didnt matter
We just played bad lol
You absolutely should have killed mages or sb the second night. Although good job on hitting both untouchables so quick. Hitting mages would have made the most sense, cause then you could have had kloudi step up her activity and hopefully be made chief and sway the vote. You should have chopped the legs out from under the main town spokespeople and make others step up.
Comments
I feel like this game went better than expected at first
yeah i converted meadows.
it was kinda way town sided, because i knew who the untouchables were, and so when masons revealed , the amount of data we gathered is huge.
I thought cory was good tho, at start, because he voted for loafery, and I scouted Loaf earlier, even before he was on the lynch table, so i knew he was evil, so it gives you a lot of data from who he votes to lynch, and who votes for his lynch, cuz then i can assume who is good/evil
then he did that 'imma give a huge speech on all the players' which basically narrows down the guessing game of who i need to scout for.
I picked phantom out of the random ppl that were awol. and just happened we got a werewolf, but honestly with the amount of data on who is towns, eventually mafia wud have died off. if u took it to probability, it was already down to 1/5 of me seer'ing a mafia, and that is with a potential like 11 turns left, which is WAY TO HIGH, for town. like the reason why groups of good knowing who each other is, is then people CAN reveal, that is why you never let good ppl other than seer, who can see, cuz if he reveals, he dies. If the townies can label people as good, and guarantee it, as the game narrows down to the end, it gets increasingly difficult for mafia.
But SB. when loaf called out he was seer, we already knew you were good. He mentioned he seer'd SB, and skydragon. so normally you would assume that 1. if he was mafia he would label 'mafia as good', but then if he dies, ppl would not believe his posts, so he would pick 2 townies.
if you were 'seer'd supposedly' and you knew you were a townsperson, and seer wasn't killed at night, then the obvious conclusion would be you voting for him, if you work out the potential scenarios of why he picked u as a town, and the implications.
but yeah, that goldmine u gave us loaf, THX. LOL, once u claimed seer, u basically know you are dead that night. or the day after. so saying nothing would have probably been better, cuz once ur role is revealed, all the information you gave made it very easy to spot, unless you planned your death and so you randomly obscured the information, which wud have been better, imo.
what messed me up was cory's vote to lynch loaf, but possible because u can change votes, i never checked back to see if it cfhanged, but it was the one that got loaf on the lynching block.
shinings death was pretty random, but lucky too.
and lissa was EXTRA inactive, which gave her away :P
But then again the setup was town favored like walls said so it really didnt matter
We just played bad lol