›

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In Register

Categories

Is this suicided? or just open..?

HazzaHazza
edited April 2012 in General
Home Leader War Leader #1 War Leader #2 War Leader #3 War Leader #4
Status AVAILABLE (0) UNAVAILABLE (11) UNAVAILABLE (6) UNAVAILABLE (1) AVAILABLE (0)
Soldiers 0 0 0 0 0
Troopers 0 0 0 0 0
Dragoons 0 0 0 0 0
Fighters 0 0 0 0 0
Laser Troopers 0 0 0 0 0
Laser Dragoons 26,632 0 0 0 0
Tanks 3,621 5,857 5,857 5,857 0
Tactical Fighters 904 3,437 3,438 3,438 0

I make they have 51% defence home..

but someone else claims its 34% home..
«1

Comments

  • FlazerFlazer
    thats ajar
  • WinterWinter
    thats ajar
  • PersonaPersona
    DEFINITELY AJAR
  • Lynog_LFC_x2ndCxLynog_LFC_x2ndCx
    defo ajar
  • MarciMarci
    edited April 2012
    damn sk is a hard game, i can't even "speal" the word jar
  • WallsOfFireWallsOfFire
    36.1% total military home 63.9% total military out
    Not a suicide though close. Just very Open

    Bare in mine this guy has 6k land. Pitiful defense Imo
    u make english cry.
  • glucosemeglucoseme
    Capitalizing 'open' was my favorite part. What was you're favourite?
  • ZealityZeality
    Capitalizing 'open' was my favorite part. What was you're favourite?
    Really?
  • LewsTherinLewsTherin
    6k land? where?
  • googlergoogler
    Unless you ask me.
  • LewsTherinLewsTherin
    Unless you ask me.
    I dont ask googler, I ask google.
  • Lynog_LFC_x2ndCxLynog_LFC_x2ndCx
    36.1% total military home 63.9% total military out
    Not a suicide though close. Just very Open

    Bare in mine this guy has 6k land. Pitiful defense Imo
    total military means nothing, its defensive units that count. he has 50% of his D out so hes tecnically not suicided in todays sk, 5 years ago he was food, now they kinda go with 2/3 of your defensive if i remember rightly
  • ModgyModgy
    36.1% total military home 63.9% total military out
    Not a suicide though close. Just very Open

    Bare in mine this guy has 6k land. Pitiful defense Imo
    total military means nothing, its defensive units that count. he has 50% of his D out so hes tecnically not suicided in todays sk, 5 years ago he was food, now they kinda go with 2/3 of your defensive if i remember rightly
    That makes as much sense as protecting anti-turtles.
  • NoSocialGroupNoSocialGroup
    Current DPA is an always has been the best way to go about it. If you're all tanks and land-skinny you should be able to send out more than %50.
  • PiePie
    36.1% total military home 63.9% total military out
    Not a suicide though close. Just very Open

    Bare in mine this guy has 6k land. Pitiful defense Imo
    total military means nothing, its defensive units that count. he has 50% of his D out so hes tecnically not suicided in todays sk, 5 years ago he was food, now they kinda go with 2/3 of your defensive if i remember rightly
    Not true.. if I was 1k lds 2k TFs then by your reasoning I am not open? Yet I am considered anti turtle which by definition is being able to break yourself twice or having less than 33% of your total military in defense, hence constant suicider... Meaning free land.

  • Lynog_LFC_x2ndCxLynog_LFC_x2ndCx
    no i just mean in this guys case^^ the one who is posted at the top, he has 50% of his defense out, his offensive units dont mean anything
  • CrashCrash
    I should hope while debating they were also busy hitting that easy land early and often :)
  • NoSocialGroupNoSocialGroup
    Should it mean something if his total offense can break his defense at home? Or just his defensive-able units acting as offense?
    Are Tac Fighters negligible in this formula?
    Shouldn't we look for a standard?

    Couldn't we just go back to DPA, which not only is the must justifiable standard across all KDs (with an inverse logarithmic scale as KD land increases), and also makes the most sense for KDs attacking (assuming land is same amongst possible targets).
  • Lynog_LFC_x2ndCxLynog_LFC_x2ndCx
    common sense is all thats needed, if you send out half your defense and get caught then its your own fault, If you can break yourself and you get owned then its your own fault.

  • NoSocialGroupNoSocialGroup
    Until arguments occur accross alliances when one AL interprets "open" one way an another AL interprets "open" in another way.
  • Lynog_LFC_x2ndCxLynog_LFC_x2ndCx
    well as far as i know its 2/3 of your defense being out is a suicide. Anti turtles are different ofcourse they go by % of total mili
  • MissMeadowsMissMeadows
    Only nerds calculate and care about this crap. If you sent out some assload of tanks you deserve every single hit you get.
  • NoSocialGroupNoSocialGroup
    Only nerds play this game, so it doesn't matter if you run off some quick calculations anyway.
    FTFY
  • ScientologyScientology
    no i just mean in this guys case^^ the one who is posted at the top, he has 50% of his defense out, his offensive units dont mean anything
    Fuck that shit, I will always calculate using total military. Defensive units only is just retarded.
  • NoSocialGroupNoSocialGroup
    Unless you take into account DPA.

    Total military = nw based -> still not the best representation.
  • PiePie
    I always use total military otherwise you lose any argument with hitting anti turtles.
  • DarubianDarubian
    I miss the days of DPA, you all over complicated things. In the days I AL'd I would defend a gang bang on this player because he might as well be fish food, I'm no pro KD builder but common sense comes into play here and this guy is lacking it.
  • TMonstaTMonsta
    Always use total military units, defensive units only is retarded.
  • LewsTherinLewsTherin
    Total mili units. Def units is retarded. Especially if antiturtle kd.
  • QwjvfiilQwjvfiil
    Im with meadows

    DPA and all that shit only matters if you are breakable
Sign In or Register to comment.