I don't think it matters, though, because unless walls or sky were the gunner (clearly not the case) at best we know that the gunner [I]thought[/I] one might be scum, and considering it's meadows lol...she could be just doing whatever for the hell of it xP
We tend to overlook meadows because of her usual trolling nature, but the fact of the matter is, she isn't stupid and shes not a noob. And, quite frankly, I don't believe she'd still be allowed to play if all she did was come here to troll. There is a method to her madness, most of us probably wouldn't have even pegged her as mafia if she didn't kill herself. I'm not saying sky is def mafia, but I'm also not prepared to write him off as town either. Just because her effects were random doesn't mean she didn't have an agenda.
I still feel sky isn't our primary suspect, this night should bring plenty of new reads to think about, but we've failed too many times letting mafia run the show. Ignoring what meadows did, because it was meadows who did it, would be unwise.
I agree, but at the same time, we don't know that she didn't have some kind of read. Remember, the bard would be soft claiming to get mafia's attention, it is possible we've missed something. And I'm not saying we keep pursuing sky over what has happened, I'm saying don't over look him because it seemed completely random.
If gunner knew mafia itd make sense but she didnt so it doesnt matter. Sky can be town or mafia but we cant determine it based on meadows actions. Cory opted to save sky so i want his opinion on the matter
Another night has ended, but this time with less bricks on the walls. A mix of water and blood has made for somewhat pink fluids. Deck Cadet was not done yet, so he called Loafery for interrogation once again. Chief Officer found Cory crying in the cargobay, eating away his panic because he cant swim. The Chief decided to make him company, so he feels safe and try not to steal an emergency boat during the night. Captain was heard yelling at someone again, but this time in front of the intercom. In these moments of crysis, he does need to make sure everyone understand he's the one in charge there. A couple hours later, someone hacked the intercom and now singing can be heard throughout the entire ship. "I just wanna tell you how I´m feeling. Gotta make you understand", then suddenly shots were heard and the intercom stopped working.
TL;DR: (even shorter version) Cory was protected Loafery was locked Captain converted someone Singing was heard.
I'm fairly certain rsoultin is the bard. On night 1 strikers failed to kill anyone, which meant either they targeted someone who was protected (rsoultin and loafery were the only 2), or they found the bard. But seeing as we have another night without a kill, again they either targeted someone who was protected or found the bard. The difference this time is the bard singing which could mean she deflected an ability, but all the abilities are accounted for except the strikers. I had a strong hunch at first, but this seals it for me.
You know that saying about the criminals always returning to the scene of the crime? It actually happened.A Striker went back down to the blast zone to make sure Gunner didn't leave any evidence that would lead to the rest of the pirates. Thing is, someone was hiding there, waiting. And who else would know beforehand what Loafery was going to do but the one who interrogated her twice. With a wrench in hand, Deck Cadet hit Loafery in the back of her head, knocking her unconscious. After that, something flipped in Cadet's mind. Repeated wrench blows were given to her head and torso, and then some kicks to the ribs. The Cadet could hear the bones breaking. After stopping a little, the lawmaker broke Loafery's nose with a punch then walked away releaved, satiated.
You didn't pick up on his hi ho dwarf song? Couldn't figure out that was why I was voting him? Then he softed cook. So yes, I was being a goof Night and Day 1, but the idea was now planted and he ran with it.
I MADE SO MUCH NOISE ABOUT HIM that there is no way that scum is that dumb.
I am neither the cook nor the bard -shrugs- nor anything special at all.
Town lynching me would be a mistake.
You already said it, Mages. Why would I bring up softing if I was the bard? That's not just chaotic scum play (and I'll admit I can be erratic as scum) but it is flatout dumb. If I'm the bard, and think that scum caught on and that was why there was no NK, why would I discuss the topic at all rather than just play dumb and keep softing? xP
Just take a look at Dole, please. If you still think it's more likely to be me, fine.
But you'd done a good job planting that I might be the cook. Dole, on the other hand, softed, and while I tried very hard to lynch him and hint at why without flatout saying it so scum could find him, he probably was easy to find because of the noise I was making.
I'm not 100% on him, but if bard got found out last night, which the singing suggests, I'd bet it's him. You can even lynch me first, but town can't afford that many mislynches
If I'm the bard, and I see someone softing bard who I think may be cook, and I'm pushing his lynch...why would I drop it when he softed cook?
Literally [I]no one[/I] had a friggin clue what I was doing. It's not like there was anyone to go RSOUL KNEW HE WAS COOK AND TRIED TO LYNCH HIM ANYWAY.
I should have kept the pressure up if I was the bard.
Comments
the leading trains were walls and sky.
I don't think it matters, though, because unless walls or sky were the gunner (clearly not the case) at best we know that the gunner [I]thought[/I] one might be scum, and considering it's meadows lol...she could be just doing whatever for the hell of it xP
I still feel sky isn't our primary suspect, this night should bring plenty of new reads to think about, but we've failed too many times letting mafia run the show. Ignoring what meadows did, because it was meadows who did it, would be unwise.
@kenshin
so sky should be evaluated on his own play, imo, not on meadows...doing whatever it is meadows is doing lol
Night 2 will end in 3 hours.
TL;DR: (even shorter version)
Cory was protected
Loafery was locked
Captain converted someone
Singing was heard.
Day 2 has started.
lynch rsoultin
Mayor cory
Protect sky from lynch today
Mayor cory
2. Fisherman has one night matchkill that is not available the night it gets converted, because conversion happens when night ends.
TL;DR:
Deck Cadet killed Loafery, a Striker
It is still daytime.
I MADE SO MUCH NOISE ABOUT HIM that there is no way that scum is that dumb.
#throwtheMonstaovertheside!
Town lynching me would be a mistake.
You already said it, Mages. Why would I bring up softing if I was the bard? That's not just chaotic scum play (and I'll admit I can be erratic as scum) but it is flatout dumb. If I'm the bard, and think that scum caught on and that was why there was no NK, why would I discuss the topic at all rather than just play dumb and keep softing? xP
But you'd done a good job planting that I might be the cook. Dole, on the other hand, softed, and while I tried very hard to lynch him and hint at why without flatout saying it so scum could find him, he probably was easy to find because of the noise I was making.
I'm not 100% on him, but if bard got found out last night, which the singing suggests, I'd bet it's him. You can even lynch me first, but town can't afford that many mislynches
If I'm the bard, and I see someone softing bard who I think may be cook, and I'm pushing his lynch...why would I drop it when he softed cook?
Literally [I]no one[/I] had a friggin clue what I was doing. It's not like there was anyone to go RSOUL KNEW HE WAS COOK AND TRIED TO LYNCH HIM ANYWAY.
I should have kept the pressure up if I was the bard.