Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
WW III: The Three Brothers Feedback/Comments (Master Document contained within!)
First things first, the following pastebin is a copy/paste from the word document I used to keep track of the game. It might be a bit sloppy but you can see everybody's roles and night actions here.
http://pastebin.com/JTDy9BSS
My thoughts for the game was to design a mafia in which people would have to talk to figure it out, including mafia members. The roles all have potential interactions. For instance, as mafia you would have no way of knowing whether you were blocked, your target was doctor protected, or if you tried to kill the 3rd brother. Miller is in the game to weaken town a little bit, and cause 3rd brother to have to question if he found a mafia brother or miller. While I think mafia was a bit too weak, I think the setup overall was very neat and played out well.
Night 1 in particularly was great
Cop SkyDragon: Investigates Mages (Blocked)
Roleblocker Cory: Blocks Skydragon
Doctor Darubian: Protect Damdred
Mafia Phantom/Unreliable: Kill Damdred (he's protected by doctor)
3rd Brother Tmonsta: Investigates Unreliable
Cory had no way of knowing if he blocked mafia. Mafia didn't know if they tried to hit the 3rd brother. Doctor didn't know if he protected the correct target. Nobody knew. But the dialogue that it started was really great.
I have to say I'm a little upset that town didn't win. That last minute bickering was really childish play.
Let's see other thoughts from me. I think the time limits was good, as it gave everybody plenty of time to vote with while setting well defined limits. By knowing when I'm going to call the vote, it limits me as a mod influencing the game by calling it too early. Though 24 hours day/night might be too long.
Anywho thats all for now. Let me know what you thought.
http://pastebin.com/JTDy9BSS
My thoughts for the game was to design a mafia in which people would have to talk to figure it out, including mafia members. The roles all have potential interactions. For instance, as mafia you would have no way of knowing whether you were blocked, your target was doctor protected, or if you tried to kill the 3rd brother. Miller is in the game to weaken town a little bit, and cause 3rd brother to have to question if he found a mafia brother or miller. While I think mafia was a bit too weak, I think the setup overall was very neat and played out well.
Night 1 in particularly was great
Cop SkyDragon: Investigates Mages (Blocked)
Roleblocker Cory: Blocks Skydragon
Doctor Darubian: Protect Damdred
Mafia Phantom/Unreliable: Kill Damdred (he's protected by doctor)
3rd Brother Tmonsta: Investigates Unreliable
Cory had no way of knowing if he blocked mafia. Mafia didn't know if they tried to hit the 3rd brother. Doctor didn't know if he protected the correct target. Nobody knew. But the dialogue that it started was really great.
I have to say I'm a little upset that town didn't win. That last minute bickering was really childish play.
Let's see other thoughts from me. I think the time limits was good, as it gave everybody plenty of time to vote with while setting well defined limits. By knowing when I'm going to call the vote, it limits me as a mod influencing the game by calling it too early. Though 24 hours day/night might be too long.
Anywho thats all for now. Let me know what you thought.
Comments
nobody talks in SK, town always deserves to lose
miller talk
meadows talk, mass claims. Flazer not reading
me foing off on glo.
loaf foing a bit crazy and antitown
killing phantom
basically SK came down to mass claiming elrelying on cop to out checks and lynch down a list
But i was right phantom and unreliable were mafia hahahaha